What is the general summary of the writings of Brutus?
Brutus argues that a free republic cannot exist in such a large territory as the United States. He uses the examples of the Greek and Roman republics that became tyrannical as their territory grew. He states that a true free republic comes from the people, not representatives of the people.
What does Brutus 4 say?
Brutus IV. Brutus proposes that the wealthy would secure control of the United States by using their power to determine the time and place of elections to make voting inconvenient or impossible for average citizens.
Who were the four writers of the anti-federalist responses?
Nonetheless, historians have concluded that the major Anti-Federalist writers included Robert Yates (Brutus), most likely George Clinton (Cato), Samuel Bryan (Centinel), and either Melancton Smith or Richard Henry Lee (Federal Farmer).
Why was Brutus an example of an Anti-Federalist?
Brutus was an example of an Anti-Federalist because he… Believed a centralized government posed a major threat to individual rights. Concurrent powers have what effect on the United States political system?
What is Brutus main concern with the formation of a federal government what parts of the Constitution does he cite to support his case?
Brutus is particularly concerned with the last clause of Article I, Section 8 (Necessary and Proper clause) which allows for the possibility of the government to possess absolute and uncontrollable power, which could smother state legislature.
Who wrote the Brutus essays?
The sixteen “Brutus” letters, addressed to the Citizens of the State of New York and published in the New-York Journal and the Weekly Register, closely paralleled the “Publius” newspaper articles and Justice Robert Yates, is the presumed author.
How many Brutus papers are there?
What were the Anti-Federalist Papers about?
Along with the Federalist Papers, the Anti-Federalist papers documented the political context in which the Constitution was born. The Federalist Papers defended the concept of a strong central government with their arguments in favor of the constitution.
What reasons does Brutus give against reducing the thirteen states into one great republic?
A large republic cannot sufficiently protect the states and the people as it is impossible to have representation, containing the sentiments, and integrity, to express the minds of the people.
What does Brutus 1 say about the Necessary and Proper Clause?
Brutus focused on the Preamble of the Constitution coupled with Article 1 Section 8. Specifically, he took exception to the idea that provisions “for the common defence, and general welfare” allow the Constitution to “lay and collect taxes” using any laws which Congress deem “necessary and proper.”